Ethical and Moral Dilemmas in Today’s Medicine

Medicine, and indeed life, asks us to act with great integrity and responsibility.

As doctors, we have the privilege of meeting people at their most vulnerable, of hearing their intimate stories, of caring for them physically and on many other levels, of helping them to make difficult decisions and being with them as they go through life-changing moments, including the end of life.

To be able to do this, we have to act with absolute integrity, honouring our own bodies and beings and honouring theirs equally, for we are equal partners in their shared care.

To a large degree medicine is a science, but it is an inexact science as people do not always behave in predictable ways, so there is also an art to medicine, especially when faced with problems for which science has no clear answer.

There are times when we are faced with moral and ethical dilemmas where the answers are not necessarily black and white, but more nuanced and influenced by factors other than science, like culture, religion, ideals and beliefs about the nature of life and how to live it.

Some of the problems we face in medicine are very challenging, like how to best spend the health dollar, limiting futile treatment, and assisted suicide. But we as a profession need to come to a collective understanding of how to best deal with these issues, and clarify what our role is, or it may be forced upon us by others who are perhaps less well equipped to make such sensitive decisions.

To be able to do this, we have to live our own lives with great integrity, and bring that same integrity to everything we do, including the practice of medicine. If we live in a way that is true, we will know what to do, for ourselves, and that supports us to know what is true for all those we are privileged to care for.

Read more

Latest Articles on the Ethical and Moral Dilemmas in Today’s Medicine

Photo of Dr FIona Williams for article by Dr Fiona Williams on "Physician Heal Thyself"

The Contagion of Fear – the Coronavirus Pandemic and Medicine

We are currently in the grip of a worldwide panic over COVID-19, or 2019-nCoV, the novel coronavirus pandemic. As I write, supermarkets are being stripped...
Photo of Dr Michael Myers for article by Dr Michael Myers on physician suicide awareness day

When the “S” Word Is Unspoken

Note: this is a highly disguised story for reasons that will be immediately obvious. I got an invitation a few months ago to give a...

Fitting in – is it really worth it?

Have you ever considered how often you do things just to fit in, to go along with friends or family, even though you feel...

6000 signatures: doctors call for the release of children held in off-shore detention centres

Many in the Australian medical profession would endorse the views of Dr Karen Phelps, GP, past president of the AMA and newly elected independent...

Evidence Based Medicine and complementary therapies – can they work together?

Evidence based medicine and complementary therapies may seem uneasy bedfellows, but this does not mean we should not explore how they may be effectively...

Wounded healers

It’s a late Friday evening in New York and Dr Michael Myers is finishing up the paperwork for his last patient as he takes...


Once again, Australian state parliaments are debating the issue of euthanasia – this time in Victoria and NSW. If the legislation is passed in...
Raindrops on screen photo by Alan Johnston for article on Mandatory Reporting by Dr Anne Malatt

Mandatory Reporting: it’s part of the problem, not the answer

Mandatory reporting, or forcing doctors to report to the relevant authorities if one of their colleagues comes to them for help and is deemed...
pills & money for article on doctors & pharmaceutical companies by Dr Jane Barker

Doctors and Pharmaceutical Companies – can we co-exist in an ethical way?

We would all agree that Medicine is about caring, about alleviating suffering. At its best, it has been renowned for its morality, its ethics,...
The sun rises and sets for an article by Dr Jane Barker on Dying at Home

Dying at home – the last gift a doctor can give their patient

Yesterday I sat with my friend of 30 years in her garden, marvelling at the beauty of a deep royal red geranium. She has...
Bullying In Medicine

Bullying – Alive and Well in Medicine

In 2015 Dr. Gabriele McMullin, a vascular surgeon, went public with stories of the bullying she had experienced as a surgical trainee, and bullying...
Doctor Jane Barker

Flaws in the System are Killing Young Doctors

In February this year a young Sydney doctor wrote: “In the year it has taken to complete my training as a junior doctor 3 of...
Doctor Anne Malatt

Why are doctors killing themselves?

Doctors are generally acknowledged to be intelligent. We are trained to care for the human body, and are considered the experts on it and...